Your cheesecake sounds good but I would do the morning after basket. Get some coffee, chocolates, make some muffins and cookies and throw a basket together. You can pick up some Godiva chocolates and coffee 1/2 off at Macy's or some department store like that. Just take off the holiday bow and you have them for anytime of the year. If you have a Williams and Sonoma store near you take a look their for some sale items. And you could bring this basket over after the party or send you dh to pick up and give it to them when you are leaving.