Sometimes you can find some of the old time candy at Cracker Barrel. I have fn introducing my kids to stuff I used to love. I also found a gas station in northern IN that sells zots. I try to stop there when we go to southern IN to visit my family.

I also like a lot of the same things everyone else does

jujubees
good and plenty
sugar daddy
sugar babies
candy cigarettes
Beemans and Teaberry gum
chik o sticks
peanut butter bars (those hard but crunchy ones that are white with brown stripes)