I'm always looking for quaint US vacations to take with just my husband our our kids. Sanibel Island was just beautiful. I never heard about Amelia Island until the honeymood thread - that looks nice. I've been to Edisto Island and Isle of Palms, Long Beach Island. I've always wanted to go to Nantucket. Where have you been to that is surrounded by H2O ( in the US)? I just heard recently about the islands in maryland & virginia that have wild horses - sounds beautiful.