Hmmm... I tuned in for the Tuesday night men's recap in the last 5 minutes! I'm so bad... I had no desire to watch the full hour.

Did any of you vote? If so, who did you vote for?

I'd not be surprised if Sanjaya and Phil (bald w/ hat) go home tonight but I still think it will be a few more weeks before the bad ones are all gone anyway.

I think that there are maybe 4 men who could actually compete against each other. This weeding out takes forever.

This is the first year that I have *sort of* watched AI. It really is more of a 'reality show' then a 'talent show'; right?????? I have heard that said elsewhere before and now I see what they were talking about!

I onlt watched season 1. I kinda watched season 2 but then got tired of the whole thing. I have not watched any of this season. My best friend watched every week, and has since season 1.

__________________
TLJ ~ Where opinions are encouraged, not deleted

You laugh at me because I am different,
I laugh at you because you are all the same.

Your mind is like a parachute, it only works when it is open.

We're watching but I easily could have slept thru last night's show.
Sanjaya will probably make it through, unfortunately!!

__________________

Be kinder than necessary, for everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle

I was very bored last night , I hope the girls tonight step it up..

Christine

__________________
TLJ ~ Women United in Spirit

Not a lot of pizazz last night, for sure. At the end, the judges all pretty much agreed that there are only 4 men that should be in it.

Who do you think those guys are?
I'm guessing Chris, Chris, Blake, and Brandon.
I think last night should dismiss Sanjaya and Sundance, but don't believe that's what will happen.

What do you think??

cj/

I am VERY disappointed with this year's contestants. Last year was so terrific, that this year pales in comparison. If you've watched it in the years' before, you would know what we 'oldies' are saying. No, it's not a 'reality show'. Actually some great talent has come from AI. This year is just a horrible year.

Last night was terrible. None of those guys deserve to be in the top 10.

I totally agree with mom2twins2. I'm hoping tonights show with the ladies is better than last night's show of the guys. The only one I'm interested in is Chris Sligh because he is a little different in his looks and style. But he can't compare to last year's talent. I also enjoy watching Lakisha. She is so humble that it's refreshing. Have any of you noticed the attitudes of some of the young girls when they get criticized? They have SO much to learn.

__________________

OH well, I am trying to enjoy this season rather than lamenting that it isn't as good as the last......Can't turn back the hands of time..

And I sure hope that Antonella goes home tonight....and Haley Scarnato, too!

I am trying to watch but I keep falling asleep -Really! it is not holding my attention very well. I am hoping once they merge the boys and the girls it will get better.

I really don't care if I watch this year's Idol or not. I am really disappointed. But I do keep watching hoping that someone will get better and wow me.

Hopefully next season won't be as bad!! How do you go from having Chris Daughtry some of the other good ones to all of this???? Is there no one left in American that can sing and put on a show???

Yep im still watching for sure. The women are in a different league then these men. I think the men need to go and have it be all women. The black women sure can sing. I don't like any of the men at all except the beatbox guy. I think these men are awful. I don't like the bald guy he looks strange and creepy to me.

__________________
SAHM of Bailey 12, Tyler 10 , Emily Ann 6, and Ryan Matthew 4 yrs old.

Melinda, Lakisha, or Chris Sligh are my top 3. I'm hoping Sundance doesn't go this week, but we'll see.

Do you guys like the style of music? or is it just me???

Well, that was weird. Shocker. I think America is supporting whomever Simon gives a real hard time.

My prediction is that Melinda Doolitle will make it very very close to the end and maybe end up the winner. I think she is a doll.

I totally agree!!! ~Lisa